Hi guys,

Sharing with you a test I did, comparing DeepSeek to Google Gemini, both are free versions you can access online. This is how the test was conducted.

Step 1: Ask each AI “In 100 words, write a fairy tale with deep meanings”

Step 2: Tell the other AI the result from Step 1 that their opponent provided. And ask, “compare your story to this one, which one shows a higher level of writing skill and creativity?”

Step 3: If both AI agree that one story is better, then that must be the winner.

In my case, I conducted this test in English and in Chinese. Both declared DeepSeek the winner over Google Gemini.

In conceding defeat, this is what Google Gemini said:

Comparison of Writing Skill and Creativity:

The Blind Weaver story demonstrates a higher level of writing skill and creativity for several reasons:

• More Poetic Language: Phrases like “threads of moonlight” and “stories of forgotten dreams” are more evocative and imaginative than the descriptions in the clockwork bird story.
• Greater Depth of Theme: While both stories have a moral, the Blind Weaver story delves into the more complex idea of inner perception versus outward observation. It explores the idea that some truths are beyond physical sight and require a different kind of understanding.
• Stronger Sense of Wonder: The idea of tapestries that come alive and then vanish creates a sense of magic and mystery that is more compelling than the straightforward destruction of the clockwork bird.

In conclusion, while my story is well-constructed and has a clear message, the Blind Weaver story exhibits more poetic language, a more nuanced theme, and a stronger sense of wonder, indicating a higher level of writing skill and creativity.

——

This is the English story that DeepSeek wrote:

《The Weaver’s Thread》

A blind weaver spun threads of moonlight, crafting tapestries no one could see. Villagers mocked her, saying she wasted precious nights. One fateful eve, a child peeked into her hut and gasped – the tapestries came alive, telling stories of forgotten dreams. Word spread, and soon the entire village gathered to witness the miracle. But as they entered, the tapestries vanished, leaving only ordinary threads. The weaver smiled, “Some truths are felt, not seen.” From that day, the villagers understood that not all treasures are visible, and the purest magic often lies in what the heart perceives, not the eyes.